Argument and Counterargument (Research Blog #9)


Research Questions:

Why are students experiencing food and housing insecurity? 

How do these issues impact students’ education and wellbeing? 

How are these issues being addressed and what more can be done?

 

My argument/thesis:

The increasing costs of college, food, and housing; decreasing financial aid; and lack of acknowledgement and recognition of the issue of food and housing insecurity has caused students to be unable to cover the costs and unable to access stable and acceptable food and housing, resulting in worsened academic performance and increased health problems. Colleges (and student bodies) and the government need to better recognize students’ needs, share the information, and find solutions to resolve the issue of unmet needs by creating and expanding programs and educating students on the resources available to them.

 

In “Poverty Is Largely Invisible Among College Students,” Sara Goldrick-Rab, an expert in the field of basic needs insecurity in higher education, explains the normalization of food and housing insecurity among college students and how some see it as a rite of passage. She details, “Stereotypes of Ramen-noodle diets and couch-surfing partiers prevent us from seeing it. They trick us into thinking that food insecurity is a rite of passage, that hunger and even homelessness among our students is normal” (Goldrick-Rab “Poverty Is Largely Invisible Among College Students”). While I do not disagree with this source, I feel that it points out an argument that I disagree with. I do not believe that student hunger and homelessness is normal nor a rite of passage. My research has revealed the harm that basic needs insecurity causes to students, including worsened academic performance and wellbeing. Lacking basic needs, and the harm that comes from it, is not a problem that should be overlooked because people think “it’s fine.” To be able to meaningfully and effectively address the issue, people need to recognize that it is a large, serious issue and that students should not have to miss meals or rely on ramen and friends just to be able to continue their education.

 

 

Goldrick-Rab, Sara. “Poverty Is Largely Invisible Among College Students.” Talk Poverty, 7 Nov. 2017, https://talkpoverty.org/2017/11/07/poverty-largely-invisible-among-college-students/. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Scouting The Territory (Research Blog #2)

Since Blog #1, I have decided to expand my topic to include housing insecurity/homelessness among college students. Taking Professor Goeller’s advice, I decided it would be a good addition to my original topic and would result in a greater exploration of impoverished students. I will now be researching food and housing insecurity among college students. The key terms that were most useful include “food insecurity college,” “housing insecurity college,” and “college student homelessness.” I found articles, books, and government documents that discuss causes, statistics, what food and housing insecurity look like, how the problems should be addressed (by colleges and by the government), and the consequences of food and housing insecurity. Wikipedia has a page titled “Food insecurity among college students in the United States” that provides some good background for the topic, including causes, prevalence, effects, and responses. Another Wikipedia article regarding basic needs talks abo...
Read more

Initial Topic Idea (Research Blog #1)

Image
For the project, I am thinking about exploring the topic of food insecurity among college students. While many recognize that the cost of college is high (and continuing to get higher), they may not consider how, due to the financial strain put on students and their families, the students may have other needs, such as food, that are left unfulfilled. Financial aid, loans, and jobs only go so far. For some, they do not cover enough. My research would likely include statistics related to the issue, the impact of food insecurity on college students’ education and health, what steps are being taken to help combat this issue, and what more can be done.
Read more

Literature Review #2

Image
  Food Insecurity on Campus: Action and Intervention Edited by Katherine M. Broton and Clare L. Cady, Foreword by Sara Goldrick-Rab Various authors contributed to this piece (see below) Citation   Food Insecurity on Campus: Action and Intervention , edited by Katharine M. Broton, and Clare L. Cady, Johns Hopkins University Press, 2020. ProQuest Ebook Central , https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.proxy.libraries.rutgers.edu/lib/rutgers-ebooks/detail.action?docID=6184603 . Summary The book discusses how increasing college costs and almost unchanging incomes in America has exposed many college students to food insecurity. Various authors contribute essays that work to address food insecurity among college students, using their own perspectives, research, and experience to approach and offer insights on the topic. They detail what the most promising strategies are, including the creation of campus food pantries and emergency aid programs, utilizing public benefits and partnerships ...
Read more